brooklyn hearth

MTA Student MetroCard Petition

Friday, December 18th, 2009

Not only are we losing B23 along Cortelyou during the week thanks to the MTA’s cuts, the changes to student MetroCards are in my mind a step too far. This petition came via Scott Stringer’s (Manhattan Borough President) office, and if you feel so inclined, you can add you name to it here:

To:  Metropolitan Transportation Authority

Jay Walder
Executive Director and Chief Executive Officer
Metropolitan Transportation Authority
347 Madison Avenue
New York, NY 10017

Dear Mr. Walder:

Hard working parents and students should not be punished for the MTA’s poor planning and mismanagement of its budget. The proposal to cut the free and reduced fare Student MetroCard program as a means of balancing the MTA budget is unacceptable and should be taken off the table immediately.

The free-fare student program accounts for less than 2% of the total MTA budget, and the State has not pulled its weight to fund this program as promised. However, eliminating such an important program to close a relatively small gap would be extremely shortsighted and detrimental to New York City’s future. While other jurisdictions rely on a yellow school bus to get their children to school, in New York City the yellow MetroCard is our school bus, which 400,000 students rely on every day to travel to school and participate in after-school activities. Cutting the Student MetroCard program is not the answer to the MTA’s budget shortfall, and we will not stand for its proposed elimination.

The MTA must act responsibly and consider a wide range of budget solutions before placing this financial burden on parents and students. We urge you to withdraw the MTA proposal to cut the free and reduced fare Student MetroCard program.

Sincerely,

(Your Name Here)

This is what Marty Markowitz ( Brooklyn Borough President) said in response to the MTA’s decision to cut services and discounted MetroCards a few days back:

Today’s vote by the MTA to eliminate or scale back subway and bus service, Access-A-Ride and discounted student fares is unconscionable, and couldn’t come at a worse time for New Yorkers not only struggling to keep their jobs, but who will soon have fewer commuting choices to get to and from the workplace. These “punitive” measures fail to equitably spread the burden of funding public transit throughout the entire MTA region. In Brooklyn, the elimination of Z subway service (forcing the J line to run local), the closing of the Lawrence Street Station overnights along the R line, changes to the G and M lines in Brooklyn and Queens, drastic reductions in regular bus service—including the elimination of weekday service on the B23, B25, B37, B39, B51 and B75, as well as weekend service on the B7, B14, B31, B45, B48, B57, B64, B65, B67 and B77—and reductions in Access-A-Ride will add up to a disproportionate burden for Brooklynites, including students and their parents, as well as our seniors with no other way of getting around.

- Liena

Tags:
See All: Kids, Transportation

  • http://www.hawthornestreet.com carrie mclaren

    Sorry, but this petition is stupid. Leave it to Marty Markowitz — a man who loves his car and considers Transportation Alternatives the enemy — to blame the MTA for cutbacks. Without more funding for public transit, the cuts have got to come somewhere.

    This Daily News writer gets it right:
    http://www.nydailynews.com/news/2009/12/17/2009-12-17_yes_shelly_you_owe_kids_a_fareless_trip_to_school.html

  • http://www.no-slappz.blogspot.com no_slappz

    The MTA Student Metrocard brouhaha is a red herring. Transportation for students is the responsibility of parents or the Department of Education. Not the MTA.

    Funding for the yellow school buses that carry grade-school kids is covered by the DOE, which means the money ultimately comes from the pockets of those paying property taxes.

    Since transportation is part of the fabric of education in NY City, the MTA bill for student transportation will eventually land in the offices of the DOE.

    About 67 cents of every dollar collected by the MTA comes from fares. The other 33 cents comes from government subsidies. Thus, the bill for students must come from higher fares and/or larger subsidies.

    Obviously the best choice is higher subsidies.

    Actually a better, though unrealistic choice, is to get the MTA union members to accept a wage, pension and benefit CUT. Not counting on that, however.

    The student MTA card is valuable. Two trips a day for 180 days of school at the current rate is $810. But the kids get three rides daily. Thus, the value of the pass can reach $1,215 this year.

    The NY City DOE already spends over $16,000 per student per year. Looks like that number will jump when the new transportation expense is included.

  • Phil

    The anger about this is palpable. Its a grotesque example of government bureaucracy at its worst. But I do notice that people will take out their anger on the closest target at hand which may be the conductor on a train or the toll booth operator or even a cleaner. Just remember that he or she are only working a job and lucky at that. The crisis is really the fault of the many from the MTA to the federal government. Even the mucky-mucks at the MTA aren’t entirely to blame.

    http://gothamist.com/2009/12/17/who_to_blame_for_mtas_doomsday_plan.php

    http://roomfordebate.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/12/16/why-is-the-mta-always-in-trouble/?partner=rss&emc=rss

  • P

    Letters should be sent to the State Legislature instead which failed to vote on Bloomberg’s plan to add millions of dollars each year to their budget and then passed a phony ‘bailout’ by taxing payrolls just before pulling $150 million dollars of state aid.

    They are pathetic and destroying New York. Jay Walder is just trying to make the best of the crappy hand he’s been dealt.